Classical or Jazz?

Classical? Jazz.

Musician?

I have long wanted to write a post on leadership using elements from Chain of Command, a pair of episodes from the Star Trek: The Next Generation series, but have struggled on where to start1—there’s just so much material to choose from.

One of the central conflicts of the story is how (and by whom) Captain Picard is replaced as captain of the Enterprise. Even before the change of command takes place, Captain Edward Jellico lists a series of orders, changing the Enterprise and how it functions in several significant, even dramatic ways. There’s no discussion, no explanation, no time for a period of adjustment, just his curt (and unfriendly) “get it done”.

Here’s where we could get distracted from this post’s topic. We could cover how Jellico’s assignment throws the Enterprise back into a Storming stage of team formation, how Picard graciously and effectively becomes a follower when necessary, how Jellico was effective despite his run-ins with the crew or a half-dozen other leadership topics of note.

But I want to focus on a single scene, a single pair of words.

First, the set-up:

Jellico becomes increasingly disappointed with his first officer, Riker, someone who has long worked well with Picard. Each new conflict with Jellico seems to point out just how well Riker’s and Picard’s leadership styles are (were?) complimentary. The conflicts escalate and then, the very trait that Picard used to single out Riker as his first officer2 causes Jellico to relieve Riker of duty, effectively firing him.

Here come the two words:

The scene is Riker’s quarters, he’s off-duty, reading a book, when Jellico enters in need of the best shuttle pilot he can get. He sees Riker’s trombone and asks “Classical?” to which Riker responds “Jazz.” Jellico’s response (“Ahh”) might be an indication that he finally “gets it”–one of the major differences between their two styles.

Classical, with a written musical score, scripted by a composer and directed by a conductor. It’s pretty clear Jellico sees himself in both roles on this ship. In a simplistic sense, if the musicians know their parts, any conductor can come in and take charge. That’s how Jellico seems to like it.

It’s a High Task / Low Relationship leadership style and it’s most effective when the follower is unable and unwilling or insecure, words that do not describe Will Riker (or the crew of the Enterprise or most orchestras). Jellico seems to assume that everyone around him is unable or unwilling if they don’t immediately and unquestioningly follow orders.3

Jazz, with a given melody and someone to set the beat, where the different musicians take turns improvising on the melody. It’s pretty clear that Jellico isn’t willing to give up that much control. It’s also pretty clear that Riker prefers this style. Someone to set the tempo and the melody (i.e., the Captain), while each talented performer is permitted to interpret and extemporize under that (limited) direction.

It’s a High Relationship / Low Task leadership style and it’s most effective when the follower is able, willing and confident, words that most certainly do describe Will Riker (and the crew of the Enterprise).

So there you have it: Classical and Jazz: two ways to make music. And two ways to captain a starship. Given the right situation, each can be effective. The trick is in matching the readiness of the follower to the appropriate leadership style.


Readers, when do you employ these leadership styles? What does it look like when you gauge the follower incorrectly?

  1. And in some sense, where to end.
  2. Riker says that it’s his “responsibility to point out any actions that may be mistakes by a commanding officer”. Compare with the Picard/Pressman conversation in The Pegasus where Picard says “I wanted someone who would stand up to me. Someone who was more concerned with the safety of the ship and accomplishing the mission than with how something looked on his record”.
  3. Note how Commander Data, who affirms Jellico and immediately and unquestioningly follows his orders, is temporarily promoted.
This entry was posted in Leadership. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *